BY EILEEN STUKANE | The 11 buildings that form the Robert Fulton Houses, between Ninth and 10th Aves., from W. 16th to W. 19th Sts., are much more than the brick and mortar that have been holding them together since they were built in the early 1960s. These New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) buildings are home to 2,166 low-income residents who live in 944 apartments—but they don’t just live there. They have grown up there, given birth there, taken care of elderly parents there. Apartments in Fulton Houses are often Ground Zero for several generations of family, all sharing the same ancestral space. A bedroom where a young daughter once slept is now the room of that daughter’s son.
Even though the development has suffered from neglect due to lack of federal funding and bureaucratic mismanagement, monthly rent for a two-bedroom apartment continues to be an average $631 in a neighborhood where two-bedrooms commonly rent for $4,752 a month. Yet, as Miguel Acevedo, president of the Fulton Tenants Association said, “The high-pressure steam system that we’ve got has been here since 1962. Every winter, at least once or twice a week, our tenants have either no heat, no hot water, no matter what the temperature is outside. They’ve gone days without heat or hot water.”
Residents knew changes had to be made within their buildings to repair deteriorating conditions, but they were caught off-guard by the details of NYCHA’s proposal for their rescue.
Those who live in corner Buildings 1 and 11—Building 1 on Ninth Ave. at W. 16th St.; Building 11 on Ninth Ave. at W. 19th St.—were particularly jolted upon learning that as part of a public/private proposal to raise what NYCHA reports is $168 million needed to repair and maintain Fulton Houses, NYCHA is considering demolition of their six-story dwellings, which for many are their generational homes.
“My mom has lived here for 59 years,” said David Nunez, who shares an apartment with his mother in Building 11. “I’m concerned about seniors like my mom, who’s 84, being uprooted. She knows the neighborhood and can walk around here with her eyes closed.”
Residents of all 72 apartments in Buildings 1 and 11 would be relocated into a new building constructed on the grounds. Then, two new luxury high-rise buildings would be built on the land they left, each high-rise comprised of 70% market-rate apartments, and 30% affordable units.
According to Jonathan Gouveia, senior vice-president, real estate development, NYCHA, these high-rises would be within the scale of the two 25-story high-rises that are currently part of Fulton Houses. The new construction would be undertaken by a private developer in partnership with NYCHA, which would retain ownership of the land and lease it to the developer.
In addition, the developer would make major repairs to the older buildings. Starting out, the aim would be to upgrade the infrastructure, replace the ancient steam heating system, fix the aging roofs, install new elevators and security systems, and take on the renovation and modernization of individual apartments, some currently mold-infested.
This—what NYCHA calls a “concept”—has been greeted with skepticism by some, and with outright protest by others.
NYCHA has never before demolished any of its own buildings.
“First, it’s a concept. We’re talking about the demolition of two low-rise buildings, the construction of two high-rise. This is just a concept to demonstrate how this could work, and showing folks how the numbers from a finance prospective works,” Gouveia said, “and one of the basic principles that we live by here is that before anybody is moved out of a building that could be potentially demolished, we’re building the new building first. Residents would go into brand-new apartments.” (Unconfirmed is reporting in the New York Times that revenue from the Fulton Houses would also help to finance repairs at Elliott-Chelsea housing.)
What’s Driving NYCHA’s Concept
When the news broke in April about NYCHA’s concept, a letter signed by Congressmember Jerrold Nadler, New York State Senator Brad Hoylman, Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer, New York State Assemblymember Richard Gottfried, and New York City Council Speaker Corey Johnson went out to Kathryn Garcia, Interim Chair and CEO of NYCHA, urging NYCHA to communicate directly with the residents of Fulton Houses.
At the time, people were piecing together rumors and fact—and still are. NYCHA presented a new rollout of its concept by holding a series of six information-sharing-and-listening sessions, two a day from May 20-22, to engage with residents of Fulton Houses. The sessions were held in the library of Bayard Rustin High School (351 W. 18th St.), where about 10 separate tables, each with a NYCHA facilitator listening to concerns, accommodated gatherings of Fulton residents.
At a May 22 session attended by Chelsea Community News, resident questions covered a range of issues: Will there be rent increases due to renovations? What about utilities? Will money generated by Fulton stay in Fulton? What if I don’t want to convert to Section 8—where does that leave me? Will I be able to have the same neighbor I’ve had for 40 years if I have to move into a new building?
The attending residents listened to NYCHA moderators David Pristin, executive vice-president for external affairs, and Gouveia, explain the federal government’s Rental Assistance Demonstration (RAD) program and the need to switch Fulton from Section 9 public housing funding to a Section 8 housing choice voucher program, which is preferred by Congress when it votes for appropriations.
“Why can’t we just get the money to do the repairs?” asked one woman seated at a table, and everyone around her nodded in agreement.
Hers was a reasonable request. But getting money to maintain public housing has become a big problem—not just in New York City, but across the nation. Figures from 2017 show NYCHA needing $32 billion for capital upkeep across the city and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) granting only about $4 billion. HUD has little desire to fund public housing with federal dollars. Our parsimonious federal government thinks it has found another way: steer cities into the public/private partnerships of its RAD program. Although RAD was created during the Obama administration, it has been ramped up during the Trump years.
Under RAD, a developer takes on the property management of public housing, and gets a federal government subsidy and reliable Section 8 rent—which costs tenants 30% of their income over 20-year renewable leases. At the same time, as mentioned earlier, that developer maintains the buildings—and in the case of Fulton Houses, builds new ones—and pays NYCHA to lease the land for 99 years. But now the property that is Fulton Houses, which could not be financially leveraged before, becomes an asset, because banks are willing to finance conventional loans against it, consider tax-exempt bonding, and perhaps, other financial deals. RAD allows a development team to leverage debt and make capital improvements, at no cost to HUD.
As Victor Bach, senior housing policy analyst, Community Service Society (CSS) said, “If the federal government wanted to, it could provide capital grants to public housing authorities to do the same thing [management and maintenance], but that’s not ideologically acceptable to Congress. We view RAD as the only medicine Washington is offering to public housing authorities to address their huge capital backlog, and we think it’s important that residents be well-informed about it and use the opportunity as best they can and minimize any risks.”
CSS has made a standing offer to the Fulton Tenants Association to visit and brief residents about how RAD conversion works.
For residents who want a greater understanding of NYCHA’s proposed switch to RAD and Section 8 vouchers at Fulton Houses, CSS offers, online, Resident Handbook: A Guide to NYCHA RAD Conversion. NYCHA has almost completed the RAD conversion of Ocean Bay Apartments in Far Rockaway, Queens, but that conversion did not include a demolition of buildings.
Meanwhile, at The Fulton Houses
“Displacement is the big concern, fear of being displaced and being relocated anywhere.” Acevedo said. When the Fulton Tenants Association met to discuss NYCHA’s proposed demolition of two buildings, “It was contentious,” Acevedo recalled. People were upset and rightfully so. I don’t think there’s any alternative in all honesty, but as [via] an investment from a private developer. The only way he’s going to try to recoup money as a profit and also to preserve Fulton Houses is through the [construction of a new] market-rate building. The New York City Housing Authority has not received much money from the federal government in decades. So where are they going to get the money to renovate? I don’t know. I would prefer an alternative, 120%. I would prefer that, but I can’t see one.”
David Nunez admits that the situation is nerve-wracking, but he sees an inevitability. “It’s public housing and it’s NYCHA. We never thought something like this would happen. We all grew up in the neighborhood. It’s prime real estate. It was bound to happen when you saw Google come in, and you saw the whole ambience of the whole community change.”
Still, that has not stopped some residents from forming the Independent Tenants Association and demonstrating on the grounds of Fulton Houses, and, recently, in front of City Hall, to demand that public housing remain public.
Jacqueline Lara, vice-president of the new Independent Tenants Association, does not believe what she hears from NYCHA spokespeople because she contacted elected officials and says she spoke with Leroy Williams, director for community development at NYCHA, when she initially heard the rumors and realized that she lived in Building 1, one of the Fulton Houses that may be slated for demolition.
“They all had no idea what I was talking about, hadn’t heard anything about it,” Lara noted, “and now everybody is, ‘Oh well, maybe it’s not a bad idea to demolish a building.’ ”
Lara repeated what so many others have voiced: “Just fix what needs to be fixed, new elevators, boilers. That’s it. Leave it the way it is. Once this gets demolished, there won’t be anymore NYCHA. There won’t be more affordable housing. At least we can afford this. I feel bad because a lot of people are going to lose their apartments. I’m not just fighting for myself. I’m fighting for everybody.”
NYCHA’s David Pristin and Jonathan Gouveia continue to refute the worry that people have about losing their homes: “We want folks to understand, and we continue to try to assure people, that if you live in public housing now, you are grandfathered in. There is no concern regarding eligibility or being kicked out.”
However, the disbelief one hears from Lara and others is likely to be an ongoing challenge for NYCHA.
At CSS, Bach understands the feelings coming out of Fulton Houses. “There is a certain amount of fear and distrust among residents and a lot of it is, I think, justified. No matter what NYCHA is planning, there’s an enormous amount of distrust, because residents have been through nearly two decades of disastrous living conditions,” Bach noted. “They’re still suffering from them. There’s a distrust of the Authority no matter what it proposes, and these are reasonable feelings for residents to have at this stage of the game.”
First, a Parking Lot, Then a Playground
One of the recent reasons residents are wary of NYCHA is that when its concept was initially proposed, the talk was about using an employee parking lot as the location for construction of the building that would house the residents of Buildings 1 and 11. Then NYCHA proposed that a better location would be on the site of Fulton Houses’ newly constructed $770,000 sprinkler playground for children, which has not yet officially opened. The sprinkler park, with its cushioned ground surface and adjacent new barbecues, were funded from the $100 million public housing package allocated by the state for NYCHA improvements in 2015.
As Bach explains, CSS and other advocacy groups wanted the money for infrastructure, but Governor Andrew Cuomo slated it for other types of improvements. “The Governor required that it not go to infrastructure but that it be divvied up among the legislators in the district to use for quality of life,” he said. Assemblymember Gottfried was able to direct $770,000 to Fulton Houses for the recreational upgrades. The sprinkler park is scheduled to open at the beginning of June.
A $770,000 investment in a play area that may be razed shortly after it has opened is baffling to Lara, who said, “That $800,000 could have paid for the boiler.”
The communication between NYCHA and residents of the Fulton Houses will continue, at a public Town Hall meeting on June 4, 6:30-8:30pm, at IS 70 (333 W. 17th St. btw. Eighth & Ninth Aves.). Visioning Sessions with Fulton residents will be scheduled throughout the summer by NYCHA.
Chelsea Community News is made possible with the help of our awesome advertisers, and the support of our readers. If you like what you see, please consider taking part in our GoFundMe fundraiser (click here). To make a direct donation and/or send feedback about the site, send an email to Scott@chelseacommunitynews.com.
Pingback: kütahya günlük apart daire
Pingback: web sitesi kurma
Pingback: Buy instagram followers
Pingback: track location by phone number
Pingback: find location by phone number
Pingback: spam
Pingback: Konya Evden Eve Nakliyat
Pingback: Konya Evden Eve Nakliyat
Pingback: konya seo uzmani
Pingback: porn
Pingback: Konya SEO Uzmanı
Pingback: Konya SEO Uzmanı
Pingback: porn
Pingback: gaziantep saat tamiri
Pingback: inovapin.com
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: prague tantra massage
Pingback: prague erotic massage
Pingback: sex
Pingback: rize tumblr
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: istanbul dental teknik servis
Pingback: gebze epoksi zemin kaplama
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: iporn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: sultangazi rent a car
Pingback: ankara travesti ilanları
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin9
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin8
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin7
Pingback: savasbaslamasin6
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin5
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin4
Pingback: https://cryptonumerics.com/
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin2
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin1
Pingback: savasbaslatmayin
Pingback: Savas-baslatmayin
Pingback: Savas-Baslatmayın
Pingback: ankaratravesti.xyz
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: edebiyat tumblr
Pingback: ankara travesti
Pingback: porn
Pingback: spam
Pingback: sex
Pingback: kadinlar
Pingback: bmw
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: fuck
Pingback: bursa travesti
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: Cocuk pornosu
Pingback: samsung taşınabilir ssd
Pingback: porn
Pingback: spinco
Pingback: animal porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: ananın amı
Pingback: jojobet twitter
Pingback: jojobet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: betgross giriş
Pingback: lugabet giriş
Pingback: vassycalvados.fr
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: travesti.site
Pingback: http://www.ciencias.uem.mz/media/com_menus/menu.php
Pingback: cratosroyalbet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: yasam ayavefe
Pingback: sikiş
Pingback: izmir travesti
Pingback: hd porno izle
Pingback: https://www.viki.com/users/whiteseotr1_465/about
Pingback: https://www.furaffinity.net/user/seocum
Pingback: https://communities.bentley.com/members/c2e5a44e_2d00_ad37_2d00_4105_2d00_a278_2d00_663a48b5fc8b
Pingback: https://www.zotero.org/seocum/cv
Pingback: https://www.bitchute.com/channel/GzD0WCo4Y77n/
Pingback: https://www.beatstars.com/whiteseotr1/about
Pingback: https://pantip.com/profile/7813328#topics
Pingback: https://pinshape.com/users/2738096-seocum#designs-tab-open
Pingback: https://freelance.habr.com/freelancers/seocum
Pingback: https://tvchrist.ning.com/profile/seocumm
Pingback: https://padlet.com/whiteseotr1_/anl-padlet-im-xw2i54k1z1w881sm
Pingback: https://seocum.gitbook.io/untitled/
Pingback: https://trello.com/u/whiteseotr1/activity
Pingback: https://www.flickr.com/people/199429455@N07/
Pingback: https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/205316754/about
Pingback: https://www.jotform.com/build/233021727199053#preview
Pingback: https://sway.office.com/bGoHpJ5GIFA7LGs5?ref=Link
Pingback: https://sites.google.com/view/seocumm/ana-sayfa
Pingback: https://profile.hatena.ne.jp/seocumm/
Pingback: çeşme transfer
Pingback: porn
Pingback: sdasdascascasd
Pingback: sex
Pingback: https://olanibitenisikenadam.com
Pingback: porn
Pingback: fuck google
Pingback: porn
Pingback: fuck
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: fuck google
Pingback: izmir escort
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: meritking giriş
Pingback: porn
Pingback: madridbet
Pingback: sikiş
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: propecia online forum
Pingback: propecia merck buy online
Pingback: A片
Pingback: stromectol tablets buy
Pingback: 2relevant
Pingback: stromectol prices
Pingback: bahis siteleri
Pingback: how to get ivermectin in canada
Pingback: buy ivermectin for humans australia
Pingback: buy oral ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectin wiki
Pingback: stromectol medication
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: ivermectin 5ml
Pingback: ivermectin human
Pingback: how to order ivermectin online
Pingback: order stromectol online
Pingback: ivermectin uk buy
Pingback: lucky lands
Pingback: madridbet
Pingback: stromectol
Pingback: stromectol tablets for humans
Pingback: ivermectin cream
Pingback: eurocasino
Pingback: eurocasino
Pingback: ivermectin dosage for covid
Pingback: meritroyalbet
Pingback: ivermectin lotion 0.5
Pingback: trcasino
Pingback: ielexusbet
Pingback: eurocasino
Pingback: furosemide 40 mg tablets online
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: madridbet
Pingback: meritroyalbet
Pingback: purchase furosemide online
Pingback: ivermectin uses
Pingback: buy stromectol online
Pingback: online ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectina piojos
Pingback: buy cz guns USA online
Pingback: ivermectin topical
Pingback: cialis generic no prescription
Pingback: online cialis prescription canada
Pingback: ivermectin in humans
Pingback: what is cialis
Pingback: generic viagra name
Pingback: cialis super active
Pingback: online casino no deposit required
Pingback: ivermectin generic
Pingback: ivermectin tablet
Pingback: ivermectin antiviral
Pingback: tadalafil liquid
Pingback: free online casino bonus usa
Pingback: tadalafil and dapoxetine
Pingback: generic viagra in usa
Pingback: side effects of prednisone in humans
Pingback: ivermectin paste for sale
Pingback: cheap generic cialis from india
Pingback: soft cialis generic
Pingback: cialis price
Pingback: where to buy cialis without prescription
Pingback: antiviral covid treatment
Pingback: cialis prescription usa
Pingback: prednisone online
Pingback: buy prednisone for pets
Pingback: how to buy cialis in uk
Pingback: tadalafil cost cvs
Pingback: cialis with dapoxetine
Pingback: purchase sildenafil pills
Pingback: cheap sildenafil 100mg
Pingback: stromectol 3 mg price
Pingback: tadalafil cheap no prescription
Pingback: cialis com
Pingback: cialis black
Pingback: sildenafil pills for men
Pingback: cialis coupon
Pingback: levitra dosage
Pingback: peptides tadalafil
Pingback: buy stromectol 3 mg
Pingback: viagra erection
Pingback: how to get cialis without a prescription
Pingback: stromectol tab price
Pingback: order viagra cialis canada
Pingback: stromectol lotion
Pingback: price for tadalafil
Pingback: cialis for men
Pingback: buy prednisone 20mg without prescription
Pingback: ivermectin online
Pingback: stromectol for sale
Pingback: ignition casino best slots
Pingback: ivermectin buy
Pingback: ivermectin uk
Pingback: ivermectin cost
Pingback: ivermectin tablets for humans
Pingback: how to get ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectin 80 mg
Pingback: stromectol price in india
Pingback: ivermectin tablets uk
Pingback: stromectol south africa
Pingback: flccc ivermectin
Pingback: flcc blackboard
Pingback: ventolin generic cost
Pingback: stromectol sales
Pingback: ivermectin 250ml
Pingback: viagra discount online
Pingback: viagra kopen
Pingback: tadalafil powder suppliers
Pingback: ivermectin 4
Pingback: stromectol 3 mg tablet
Pingback: Conclusion For Expository Essay
Pingback: relx
Pingback: hp sunucu servisi
Pingback: exchange online plan 2
Pingback: http://www.ristrutturazioni-smart.it/component/k2/itemlist/user/1078623
Pingback: next page
Pingback: Sendiviç Panel
Pingback: Some Penn South Residents Push Back at Fulton Houses Plan – Chelsea Community News
Pingback: Penn South Residents Join Pushback of Fulton Houses Plan – Chelsea Community News
Pingback: CB4 Proposal Counters NYCHA’s Vision for Demolition at Fulton Houses – Chelsea Community News
Pingback: CRDC Panel Sees City Reps, Residents, Advocates Discuss Future of Fulton Houses – Chelsea Community News